A remodel offers the chance to transform an existing home, while new construction provides complete creative freedom. Understanding the benefits and challenges of each option makes it easier to move forward with confidence. If you’re considering either of these options for your home in Monterey County, RDD offers professional drafting, design, consulting, value engineering, engineering coordination, and permit facilitation. Here’s our breakdown of the most important information you should know when deciding whether to rebuild or remodel.
Remodeling an Existing Home
A well-planned renovation can completely transform a home while maintaining its character. Essentially, you can keep the best parts while remodeling others. For many existing homes, this is a win-win that’s hard to pass up on, although the process can be a bit disruptive.
Pros of Remodeling
- Preserves character and history: Older homes often have architectural details and craftsmanship that can’t be replicated in new builds. Remodeling allows you to modernize while maintaining what makes it one-of-a-kind.
- Potential cost savings: Depending on the scope of the project, a remodel can be more affordable than new construction since the foundation, structure, and major systems are already in place.
- Faster timeline: Remodels are often quicker than starting from scratch with a brand-new build. That said, extensive remodels can bring them closer in parity, so it’s well worth investing in quality inspection and drafting services.
- Established neighborhood: If you love your location, remodeling lets you upgrade your home without leaving a desirable neighborhood.
- May increase home value: Strategic upgrades, like kitchen and bathroom remodels, can significantly boost a home’s resale value.
Cons of Remodeling
- Unpredictable costs: Hidden issues, such as outdated wiring or utilities that are unsafe or don’t meet code, plumbing surprises, or structural concerns can add unexpected expenses. This also includes mold, water damage, rot, insect infestation, or lead/asbestos hidden from view until demolition. If any hazardous materials are found, waste removal costs can vary significantly.
- Limited flexibility: Remodelling is mainly contained to the existing footprint. This is likely to restrict layout changes. A home addition can help with this. Zoning laws and budgets will affect the addition size and style.
- Potential for disruptions: Living in a home during renovations can be disruptive, particularly if you work from home.
- Permit and zoning challenges: Older homes will require special permits or compliance with local regulations, adding time and complexity to the process.
Cost Considerations
Remodeling costs vary significantly based on the project scope, materials, and any surprises uncovered along the way. Minor cosmetic updates, like fresh paint and new fixtures, are relatively affordable. Even remodeling a couple of rooms will come with a relatively low price tag compared to that of a new build. On the other hand, major structural changes, such as adding floors or reconfiguring foundations, can add up quickly. The age of the home will play an important role in the final cost as well—older homes may require extensive updates to bring electrical, plumbing, and insulation up to modern standards.
New Construction
Building a home from the ground up is an opportunity to create something entirely your own. Everything is new, efficient, and built to exactly fit your vision for the home.
Pros of New Construction
- Total Customization: No compromises, no weird layouts, no fighting with existing structures. Every detail, from the floor plan to the finishes, is designed to match your vision.
- Energy Efficiency & Modern Tech: New builds can incorporate the latest in high-performance insulation, energy-efficient appliances, and smart home systems for a home that’s both sustainable and high-tech.
- Fewer Maintenance Issues: Since everything is brand new, you won’t have to worry about leaky roofs, outdated wiring, or failing plumbing for years to come.
Cons of New Construction
- Higher Upfront Costs: In almost all situations, new builds come with a higher total cost. Land acquisition and permits alone are unique to this option, and the time, labor, and materials costs tend to be higher than what remodels usually require.
- Longer Timeline: Unlike a remodel, which can be completed in stages, new construction usually requires one long process without disruptions. From securing permits to final inspections, it’s a months-long journey.
Cost Considerations
New construction is a significant investment. One of the biggest cost factors is land, so if you don’t already own a lot, purchasing one adds no small amount to the overall price tag. In the areas under the Monterey Peninsula Water Management District, water credits will be needed. Custom homes tend to cost more per square foot than renovations due to labor, materials, and the extensive planning involved.
On the other hand, there are cost savings to be found with new construction. New builds offer long-term savings in the form of energy efficiency and minimal maintenance expenses. When working with a premium home designer and competent construction firm, there should be no surprise repairs or expensive system upgrades for the foreseeable future.
Design Your Dream Remodel or New Home with RDD
Choosing between remodeling and new construction comes down to your priorities and your budget. No matter which path you take, RDD has decades of experience working with homeowners and construction professionals in Monterey County. We can work with you to develop plans for a home that fits your vision. What can we design for you?
